Laurel & Hardy

28. Liberty (1929)

‘Liberty’ is a great comedy and, for me, ranks in the top four of Laurel & Hardy’s silent shorts. It’s strange in a way when you think that a good portion of the film was actually the unwanted bits, the cast-offs from their previous outing. That may seem remarkable, but it’s absolutely true. A number of scenes, where the boys are wearing each others’ trousers and have to swap back, were shot and then discarded in the cutting room, in order to shorten the length of ‘We Faw Down‘ (1928). These scenes were then used and expanded and given a beginning and an end to create an entirely new film in its own right.

liberty2The plot of ‘Liberty’ is fairly simple (as it is in all the boys’ best films). Stan & Ollie are freshly escaped convicts, still in their stripey prison uniforms and fleeing from their pursuers. A pre-arranged getaway car picks them up and the boys hastily discard their prison gear and begin to change into their trademark suits and derbies. It’s not long before a police motorbike is hot on their tails and the boys have to make a quick exit from their vehicle. This is quite a stunt in itself as both actors leap from the moving vehicle (the film must be sped up here, but the effect is wonderful) and they pretend to admire a parked car, until the motorbike cop tears past.

They then emerge from behind the car and realise that they are wearing each others’ trousers. The rest of the picture is taken up with the boys attempting to swap trousers.

This is such a simple idea, but it’s just so funny. The way they try to discretely hide behind boxes, down alleys or in stationery taxi-cabs, only to be discovered in compromising positions by passersby (including the first appearance in a Laurel and Hardy film by Jean (Jeanie Weenie) Harlow), who are left quite shocked by their discovery, unsure as to what these two fellas have been, or are trying to get up to.

Even though Laurel & Hardy films are renowned for being ‘innocent’ and ‘good, clean fun’, I love this subtle and cheeky adult theme that underlies these sequences. This is not an isolated occurrence either, as little adult jokes do pop up from time to time in others of the boys’ films, such as the scene in ‘Angora Love’ (1929), where landlord Edgar Kennedy enters the boys’ room to tell them “I want you guys to know this is a respectable hotel!”, whilst in the background, a lady is seen walking along the corridor to her room followed by a sailor, who roguishly cocks his hat. A seemingly innocent gesture that alludes to something far less innocent. Better still, a string of sequences that has me crying with laughter every time, is in ‘That’s My Wife’ (1929), where Ollie is trying to discretely retrieve a stolen necklace from the down the back of Stan’s dress (!) Again, they keep on being discovered in hilariously compromising positions, which I just find uproariously funny. Anyway, I digress…

During these scenes, the boys attempt, unsuccessfully, to switch trousers behind a fishmonger’s, among crates full of the fruits of the sea. While they’re in the throws of changing, a live crab is knocked out of a crate and it falls into the back of Ollie’s trousers, that are still being worn by Stan.  The boys get rumbled once more before they’re able to complete the clothing exchange and so proceed on foot, down the street and then the crab starts to pinch Stan…right in the middle of his daily duties!


As mentioned above, the trouser-changing sequences were filmed originally as part of ‘We Faw Down’ (1928). They were cut from the film at the point where Stan and Ollie are escaping from ‘One-Round Kelly’s’ apartment, after being found with his girlfriend and minus their clothes (see the previous blog for more details). To get away the boys speedily get dressed and jump from the ground floor window into the street. In the original scene the boys are mistakenly wearing each others’ trousers, hence the need to swap back. This then forms the basis for the entire middle section of ‘Liberty’.

Once again, I find myself repeating the same phrase, that much of the best comedy in Laurel & Hardy movies is in reactions – and so it is here. Stan and Ollie’s embarrassed reactions at being discovered, literally with their pants down, combined with the shocked and/or disgusted reactions of the unsuspecting passersby are just wonderful. I especially like the way the burly builders look over our boys, (with trousers around their ankles), with much suspicion as they exit the construction site elevator. It’s on this same construction site that the film’s finale takes place.

liberty6‘Liberty’ then develops from a farce into a ‘thrill’ comedy seamlessly, as the boys suddenly find themselves tottering along the girders of an unfinished skyscraper, hundreds of feet in the air, with the aforementioned crab still nipping! ‘Thrill Comedy’, very much like ‘Horror Comedy’, was a very popular genre during the twenties and arguably the most famous for plying this trade was fellow Hal Roach star Harold Lloyd, who’s most iconic image was from his film Safety Last (1923), wherein Lloyd dices with death at great heights, ending up hanging precariously from the hands of a giant clock. Interestingly, Randy Skretvedt notes that the Western Costume Company building used by the Roach Studios for the skyscraper scenes in ‘Liberty’ had also been used for the filming of the 1927 ‘Our Gang’ comedy ‘The Old Wallop’. In addition, a number of other productions, including Harold Lloyd’s ‘Feet First’ (1930) and MGM drama ‘Day of Reckoning’ (1933) to name but two, were all filmed in and around the same group of neighbouring buildings. For more in-depth information relating to the films and locations of all these thrill comedies, check out Randy’s invaluable (and now in paperback) ‘Laurel & Hardy: The Magic Behind the Movies, but I also strongly recommend ‘John Bengston’s wonderful blog entitled ‘Laurel & Hardy’s Liberty Rooftop’. 

This thrill sequence is fabulously constructed and bravely shot by both actors and crew. During the ‘This is Your Life’ programme dedicated to Laurel & Hardy in 1954, Director Leo McCarey recounted a story of the shooting of ‘Liberty’ where Stan became scared of the dangers involved in shooting these scenes and so, in an attempt to reassure and comfort him, Ollie demonstrated how any fall would result in them landing on a ‘safety’ platform a few feet down. However, the safety platform broke and Ollie fell a further twenty feet, landing in a safety net.

The resulting film was well worth the efforts and risk involved as it’s a real Laurel & Hardy masterpiece. It’s a perfect silent comedy, as it’s so visual in nature, from start to finish. I could have easily described each scene, gag by gag, but I would rather encourage you to watch the picture for yourself. You’ll find a film that is full of heart and humour and it’s a must-see for any fan of the boys, or of silent comedy or just by anyone at all.

Let us know your thoughts on ‘Liberty’ and indeed on this blog – do you agree or disagree with us? Please share your comments with us in the box below or on our Facebook or Twitter pages.

24 thoughts on “28. Liberty (1929)”

  1. I fully agree that is one of the best silent films made by Laurel and Hardy. I have shown my class of 6/7 year old children a fair few L&H shorts, the only silents being Liberty and Big Business. I have shown at least 10 sound shorts but when asked their favourite film, most say “the skyscraper one” haha! A true classic!

  2. Ive thoroughly enjoyed coloring a number of photos from Liberty. One of my favorite movies of the boys.

  3. I saw “Liberty” several years ago at the Virginia Theatre in Champaign, Illinois, topping off a concert featuring the Virginia’s theatre organ. The audience was on the older side — I think a few of them might have been in their 90’s, which meant they could have conceivably seen “Liberty” as children during its original release. The response to the movie from me and the rest of the audience was non-stop laughter. I’ve seen some silent Chaplin and Keaton movies in the same theatre, but they didn’t get as strong a response. I did not know the pants-switching scene was originally shot for another movie. Its appearance in “Liberty” appeared seamless. The thrill comedy portion of the movie truly worked for me on the “thrill” level. I had read how those scenes were shot, by building a set on top of a tall building in Los Angeles, but that knowledge didn’t dampen the giddy nervousness I felt as I watched Laurel and Hardy teetering on the girders. The pacing of the gags in “Liberty” was relentless. It’s my understanding that many Laurel and Hardy films were paced rather deliberately, in response to the frenetic pacing of other slapstick comedies of the time. But I don’t think that’s the case with “Liberty”.

    1. Thanks for your comment Jim, that sounds like it was a great night. I recently watched a Buster Keaton film on the big screen as part of a larger audience and the laughs were not as numerous as when I’ve watched Laurel & Hardy in similar circumstances. The boys just had ‘it’. Not sure if you’ve seen ‘We Faw Down’ but you can see how the pants-switching sequences would have slotted in to it at the right point, but as it was, we got another great comedy to savour. Thanks for visiting the blog. We’ll be looking at and discussing ‘Wrong Again’ over the weekend, so watch this space.👍🏻

  4. What’s especially interesting is that they shot the “high and dizzy” sequence *twice.* The first version had Tom Kennedy as a construction worker; stills exist from this early, scrapped version of the scene. (Kennedy is still in the movie, but now as a prison guard chasing the escaped convicts Stan and Ollie.) This was shot from October 2 through 17, 1928. All I can guess is that previews indicated that the sequence wasn’t what it should have been, because L&H and the company went back to the top of the Western Costume Company building on November 13 and shot retakes through the 18th. This time James Horne was directing (his first time with L&H) instead of Leo McCarey, so I would guess that at least a third of the footage in the film was made under his guidance.

  5. “Liberty” Is one of the top best Laurel and Hardy silent or talkie films. 🙂 And there are many, many, mannnnny, adult jokes in their films. I would actually say the “Good clean fun” shorts and movies are just as equal to the “Adult humor” jokes in their films.

    Their first mistake vs The Live Ghost
    That’s My wife vs Helpmates
    Liberty Vs Blockheads

    and so on…

    A lot of fans in the community get really up in arms when it comes to adult jokes or even what seems to be queer/LGBTQ jokes in their films, they get really upset, and it is not about calling the guys or characters gay or anything it’s about enjoying the joke and laughing at it. How many movies has Stan either dressed up as a woman or got married to a man, mentioned marrying a guy or accidentally married Ollie? I can count at least three.

    I would love to talk to you or anyone else, in a CLEAN WAY about the adult humor in their films someday, or I trust that you will make a blog about their adult humor, i would love to read it <3

    Were the Film Laurel and Hardy Gay? Maybe
    Were the REal Laurel and Hardy gay or Bi sexual, I dont know, but people in the community really need to chill because there is soooooo much adult humor in their films and i enjoy it in an adult, non-sexual way. It's cute and funny.

    LIke I would be crucified if I said about "Liberty" That must have been a happy crab in their pants."

  6. that was brilliant!! funny and genuine seat of the pants thrills all wrapped up together -how did they do those scenes on the skyscraper?? were they really up that high?? amazing. Best one yet I think – though perhaps Finishing Touch was funnier overall actually.

  7. Hello,
    I have find this trivia on IMDB:

    “The building under construction in 1928 that served as a location for the climactic scenes in this short was the Western Costume building at 939 South Broadway, Los Angeles. The building still stands (as of 2018) just South of the United Artists Theatre building (1926). While The Boys are on the girders, views to the South show the then-new Western Pacific Building (1925) at 1031 South Broadway; the triangular block of buildings at South Broadway where Broadway Place once cut an angle from Tenth Street (now Olympic Blvd.) and Broadway to Main Street (the entire block, including Broadway Place, has been replaced by an apartment complex); a large sign advertising the Sunday Examiner newspaper, atop the 10-story Los Angeles Railway Building (1925), which is kitty-corner across the street from the Herald Examiner headquarters; and in the distance, the twin steeples of St Joseph’s Catholic Church (1901-1903, destroyed by fire in 1983) at 12th and South Los Angeles Streets”

    what do the dates in brackets mean: 1926 at the United Artists Theater building, or 1925 at the Los Angeles Railway Building and Western Pacific Building? These are not the dates when these buildings were built. Maybe these are the shooting dates. This curiosity is written in an incomprehensible way and this slightly undermines its credibility. And I can’t check it because I don’t know the topography of Los Angeles that well.

    sorry for my English.

    1. Hi and thanks for visiting the blog. What makes you think that the dates are not the dates that the buildings were constructed? That is what it usually means when written in this way. The Western Pacific Building was indeed constructed in 1925, just as it says here. So, I think that is the answer.

Leave a Reply to Jim Meadows Cancel reply