Laurel & Hardy

27. We Faw Down (1928)

Just as Laurel & Hardy’s 1927 silent short ‘Hats Off‘ was the genesis of their later talkie ‘The Music Box’ (1932),  ‘We Faw Down’ has the bragging rights of being the inspiration for one of the boys’ best-loved feature films ‘Sons of the Desert’ (1933).  Further still, not content with being the tiny two-reeler ‘seed’ that spawned a full-length masterpiece, ‘We Faw Down’ was also looted for its finale gag for another of the boys’ features, 1938’s ‘Block-Heads’. Further again, a telephone gag, where the boys pretend a call is from ‘their new boss’ is looted for use in ‘Their First Mistake’ (1932); and even further than that, a number of sequences that were completely cut out in the editing room, were taken and expanded to make Stan and Ollie’s very next release, the wonderful ‘Liberty’.

So, with all this rich material contained in one small film, surely ‘We Fawn Down’ must be one of, if not THE best of the boys’ short films…yes?? Well…err, no actually – it’s not. It’s an amusing little Laurel & Hardy outing for sure, but one of their very best, it ain’t.


The first notable thing about this movie, from the get-go, is our friend Leo McCarey‘s billing as ‘Director’. We’re used to McCarey’s name appearing at the start of every L&H film, of course, but usually as ‘Supervising Director’, whatever that means in reality (come to think of itif the studio were happy to play that game, one has to wonder why Stan Laurel’s name couldn’t have appeared as ‘Supervising Director’ for every Roach film – but what do I know!)

As we discussed in a previous blog, McCarey’s influence in shaping Stan and Ollie into ‘Laurel & Hardy’ cannot be downplayed. His guiding hand slowed the speed of the comedy down from frantic slapstick to a gentler, softer pace. His direction, therefore, in ‘We Faw Down’, is very evident, or to put it another way, is about as subtle as a jealous boyfriend’s machete (that line will make more sense if you’ve actually watched the film!).

The film’s greatest hindrance is the incredibly slow pace. Don’t get me wrong, the boys could stand in front of a camera and not move for the full two reels and I’d probably still enjoy it, but I can’t help but feel that many of the scenes could have used a little injection of something.

As mentioned above, the plot is very close to that of ‘Sons of the Desert’. The boys are desperate to get away from their incredibly stern wives, played by Bess Flowers and Vivien Oakland (better known by L&H fans as the Sheriff’s wife in ‘Way Out West’ (1937)) and go for an afternoon of Poker at their ‘boys’ club’. There are some wonderful facial expressions in the first few shots, both from the fierce and overbearing wives and also the plotting husbands in the adjoining room – Ollie’s face in particular, when he thinks his wife has seen him gesticulating to Stan, is just wonderful. Babe Hardy is the master of provoking an immediate burst of laughter with just a look or expression.

After pretending they’ve received a call from ‘their boss’, who’s requested their presence at the Orpheum Theatre (as all good bosses do!) the boys excuse themselves and make their way into town (hilariously tripping over a small hedge by the door as they go).

Whilst they’re out, and here the plot mirrors ‘Sons of the Desert’, a fatal disaster occurs unbeknownst to the boys. On this occasion, the Orpheum Theatre burns down and we’re treated to some wonderful old footage of a vintage, horse-drawn fire engine, charging hell for leather down the street, apparently on its way to the burning theatre. This event, naturally, makes the newspaper headlines and the newspaper makes its way into the hands of the waiting wives…

we faw4Meanwhile, back in town…the boys become swiftly embroiled with a couple of young ladies, played by Vera White and Kay Deslys (Their Purple Moment (1928), Should Married Men Go Home (1928)). Deslys, who plays the girlfriend of ‘One-Round Kelly’, a boxer with a face that could stop a clock, loses her hat in the gutter, under a parked car, just as our heroes are walking past. Being the gentlemen that they are, Stan & Ollie attempt to retrieve the hat and end up getting soaked by a passing street sweeper. The ladies, feeling sorry for them, invite them back to their place, to dry their clothes out.

The usual mix-up then plays out, with ‘One-Round Kelly’, played by George Kotsonaros,  eventually walking in on them and becoming immediately jealous – and this is where the machete comes in…(see above)

wefaw13Still in a state of undress, the boys leap out of the window, witnessed by their wives, who just happen to be on their way to the theatre, to discover what has happened to their husbands! Rather than confronting them immediately, the wives run home and wait for the dirty rats to come home.

According to Randy Skretvedt’s ‘Laurel & Hardy: The Magic Behind the Movies‘, this scene originally had Stan & Ollie exit the window, mistakenly wearing each others’ trousers. There then followed a number of sequences where the boys would try to discreetly swap back, but they keep on getting discovered. These are the scenes that sadly ended up on the cutting room floor, but happily became their first short of 1929: ‘Liberty’.

Back at home, the boys are forced to tell their wives all about their afternoon’s entertainment at the theatre, which Ollie attempts in a rather amusing fashion, with Stan out of sight, miming in a charadesesque kind of way. There are some funny moments as Ollie misinterprets Stan’s mimes, I particularly liked Ollie’s version of Russian dancing!

In the end, the boys spot the newspaper headline and realise the game is up and they are chased out of the door by Mrs Hardy (Oakland), brandishing a shotgun. The finale gag is wonderful and much better than the ‘Block-Heads’ re-creation ten years later.  The boys run through an alleyway, in an attempt to escape the punishment of Mrs. Hardy’s shotgun and as she empties both barrels, about a dozen half-dressed, presumably adulterous men leap out of numerous windows and run for their lives.

Randy Skretvedt recalls Leo McCarey remembered how dangerous this shot was to film, with all these men leaping out of second-story windows. The gag was captured in one-take and really is a joy to behold.

In conclusion then, ‘We Faw Down’ has all the right ingredients, but the pace lets the film down.

Do you like ‘We Faw Down’? Let us know your thoughts on Facebook, or by using the comments box below.

17 thoughts on “27. We Faw Down (1928)”

  1. “We Faw Down” probably has the greatest number of individual closeup shots of Stan and of Ollie reacting and changing expressions. I could be wrong, but I can’t think of any other film that has a scene with more closeups of L&H than “We Faw Down” has during its final minutes. I like the shot of Stan and Ollie in the puddle by the curb, with their hats floating by.

    Stan has some great expression changes when he finally reads the newspaper’s headline, as it sinks in what big trouble they are about to be in with their wives. Of course, Ollie has some great expressions, too. There’s a buildup of comic suspense while Stan tries to alert Ollie, who is now doing a hula-hula dance with a lampshade as a “skirt”. Then the tension is broken (at least for us) when Stan starts laughing about Ollie’s attempt to lie his way out of the situation. I like how Ollie tries not to laugh himself, walking his fingers over the arm of the seat he has settled down in.

    I agree that a lot of the film seems to move along just a little too slowly. The scene where they are sitting at the table in bathrobes could have been shorter, but I have no idea how it originally played in theatres in 1928. Maybe it got a lot of laughs in previews, so they kept the pace slow. it would be interesting to see how the film might have been as a 3-reeler, with the switched pants and the crab pinching Stan. Someone did do an edit on YouTube, but then included all the skyscraper footage (which wasn’t filmed until after “We Faw Down” was officially completed), so it plays too long and disjointed that way.

    Overall, I would have to say that We Faw Down is very good, especially for all those closeups of L&H.

    1. Yes you’re right, I also felt that Stan laughing at Ollie at the end was slightly out of character. Not to the extent of ‘Early to Bed’, but it didn’t sit right with me all the same. Thanks for your comments.

    2. Stan’s “derisive” laughter is totally in character for 1928, when he had a little more “balls”. And Ollie’s acceptance of it — he starts laughing himself at the absurdity of it all — is perfect. They were fairly different people in 1928 than in, say, 1932.

      1. You could be right Chris, as you say, Stan is a little more ballsy in the silents. His character does get more passive into the talkies, with possibly the exception of ‘One Good Turn’, where Stan flips! Funnily
        enough, I think it was in my previous blog that I said that,
        one should always keep the film in question in context of the time it was shot and it’s place within the L&H canon. Thanks again Chris, good point, we’ll made.

  2. Every considers this film’s one of their weakest but when I saw it in a screening at a Toronto cinema — approx 150 people including kids and parents — the laughter was so loud people on the street were wondering what the noise was. I’ve never seen that with any other film — Laurel & Hardy or otherwise. It’s a marvellously subtle film that plays spectacularly with an audience.

    1. Great comments Chris, that’s a really nice insight. Watching films on the big screen and with a large audience can always give a movie a different vibe. But as you say, if you can directly compare that experience to other L&H movies, then that’s a big tick for ‘We Faw Down’. Thanks for commenting 👍🏻

  3. Some very funny bits but the direction was a bit uneven – though the first scene of Ollie on the sofa sitting back to reveal Stan was clever I thought – Ollie’s acting was excellent throughout in his naughty boy caught out moments especially dancing with the lampshade hula skirt then seeing the headline! – and I was very impressed with the speed of the newspapers in those days! Who needs 24 hour rolling TV news? 😉 loved the nose /eyebrow – throat /tongue reflexes and the fact Stan did it to his wife and got the same reaction!

    1. Thanks Geoff, there’s some nice stuff in this one. In fact, the guest on my latest podcast listed this as their favourite silent short and had some interesting things to say about it. Have you checked out any of the podcasts yet?

      1. just listened to the first one – very nicely done – good to hear Stan’s comments – will catch up with the others asap

  4. Actually this is my favorite L&H silent. I love the reactions from Stan at the table when he and the girl are playing around. So funny! Love this film!

    1. Thanks is for visiting the Blog, Rae. I’m glad you like this film so much. There are some great scenes, especially the one around the table. I’ll be doing a complete re-write of this blog in a few weeks and I know I will have a better appreciation for it.
      Thanks for taking the time to comment.

Leave a Reply